Eli's Tavern, Milford
So I'm from Milford. Every once in a blue moon, I drag myself back to town to check in on the old friends and see what everyone is up. If I'm at Eli's, I'm usually not eating if you catch my drift.
That said, they actually make some pretty decent food. The go-to has gotta be the Steak and Cheese Egg Rolls (I cannot get a good picture of these things, I've tried and it always looks horrific). The Crab Cakes were good for pub fare.
But this s'mores in a jar thing (below) might be the big winner. Bring a chick here and get that for dessert and she'll fall in love. They also make a MASSIVE Belgian pretzel with beer cheese that is a dope standalone item for pre-booze preparations.